Andy Cohen Stumped Captain Lee Rosbach with This Below Deck Question

As a man known for his witty quips and interesting figures of speech, Captain Lee Rosbach is rarely ever left speechless. But there’s a first time for everything, and for this Below Deck boss, it happened on the November 23 episode of Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen. 

During a game of “Who! Would! You Keep!?” Andy Cohen asked Captain Lee to make some very difficult decisions when presented with various pairs of past and present yachties. 

“Captain Lee, you said you wouldn’t hesitate to let a crew member go, so let’s see you put down the hammer and give someone the axe,” said Andy. 

Captain Lee breezed through the first few choices, picking alum Kate Chastain over new Chief Stewardess Francesca Rubi and Chef Rachel Hargrove over Chef Ben Robinson. Andy was even particularly surprised when Captain Lee went for Rhylee Gerber instead of Kat Held. However, the rapid fire speed of Captain Lee’s answers quickly came to a halt when Andy served up a question that stumped him: “Who would you keep? Eddie or Kelley?”

“Wow. Now that one, that’s tough,” Captain Lee explained, noting that he could never make that decision. “Their maturation level from the time I got them to the time that they came back and Eddie this year was just knocking it out of the ball park. That’s a tough one.” 

Want more Below Deck? New episodes air every Monday at 9/8c or catch up on this season through the Bravo app.