Scheana Shay Shared an Opinion About Tom Schwartz That Truly Shocked Andy Cohen

Andy Cohen’s games aren’t all, well, fun and games.

On Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, the talk-show host is known to pry deep truths out of his guests by having them play seemingly innocent games. And on the March 1 episode of the late-night show, Scheana Shay shocked Andy by sharing a controversial opinion about her Vanderpump Rules castmate Tom Schwartz. 

During her appearance in the Clubhouse, Scheana played a game titled “Tom or Katie, Pick Your Matey.” She was asked to choose either Schwartz or Katie in a variety of him-or-her questions, including “Who has a bigger ego?” For that question, Scheana chose Katie. But for the next one, she answered “Schwartz” — and Andy was visibly surprised. 

“Who has better style?” Andy asked. After a very brief moment of consideration, Scheana answered, “Schwartz.” Andy raised one eyebrow and murmured, “Wow, oh boy.”

The answer is a bit surprising, since — spoiler alert! — Scheana and Tom Sandoval both told Schwartz he could use a wardrobe overhaul during the March 1 episode of Vanderpump Rules. The “Good as Gold” singer has also commented on the decor in Schwartz’s new home, which (she believes) leaves a bit to be desired. 

However, Scheana did choose Katie for some of her answers. When Andy asked who has “the bigger freak number,” Scheana responded, “Katie, for sure.” She also confessed that she prefers Katie’s “post-divorce apartment” to Schwartz’s new pad, and that she would rather have Katie babysit her child. 

Watch Vanderpump Rules on Bravo Wednesdays at 9/8c and the next day on Peacock. And catch up on all past seasons of Vanderpump Rules on Peacock.