Wondering What to Get Your New Boo? These Valentine's Day Gifts Won't Rock the Boat

When it comes to new relationships, for every bout of butterflies and skipping hearts comes a fair share of awkward moments. From deciding who pays the check to navigating that fateful first kiss, to meeting the family and exposing your quirks, navigating new love is unavoidably uncomfortable. And of course the pinnacle of new romance jitters comes with the ever-uneasy “What are we?” talk (cue the sweaty palms).

Depending on which side of that critical convo you and your new boo are on, a certain day in February may have you feeling especially anxious. What does one gift a special someone for Valentine's Day when diamonds and roses just feel too serious? Calm your cupid-induced jitters by picking up one of the below cute and casual tokens of your love ... I mean like. 

Throw in a bottle of your favorite shared spirit along with this copper bar set for a ready-made nightcap kit. 

For the brand new boo, a pair of stylish socks is a fail-safe gift that will hopefully keep your new guy from getting cold feet in more than one way. 

Stylish guys will dig this on-trend signature applique crewneck by Commes des Garcons.

Nothing says “let’s make memories together” like this super-rare throwback Polaroid camera. 

Dapper beaus will really appreciate this eyecatching silk tie by Bonobos. 

These soft chambray boxers are the perfect cheeky gift for the new man in your life. 

Bring out your new love's sentimental side with this antique brass pressed frame to treasure a photosnap or ticket stub from an early date. 

Cute and quirky, this hand-poured soy candle is an adorable way to set the mood while letting your new interest know how you feel. 

With a tracklist featuring “La la For You” and “Old Time Lovin’,” this iconic record by Al Green provides the perfect Valentine’s Day soundtrack. 

If your perfect date night is a trip to the movies, put your own names in lights with this mini marquee inspired by cinema signs. 

A burst of attleya orchids, sambac jasmine, freesia, and rose petals comprise this super sexy fragrance for your new love to spritz on before your next hot date. 

You can never go wrong with something sweet and this pretty box of handcrafted sugar-dusted truffles is extra special: The Queen of England has added the London chocolatier to their list of Royal Warrants. 

Small, sparkly and totally chic, this leather zip-around wallet by Furla is sure to put a smile on your date's face.

Prime your partner’s pout for smooching with this mask by K-Beauty brand Kocostar that moisturizes dry lips. 

For a gal that knows her way around the kitchen (or wants to get better!) gift this coffee table-worthy collection of recipes by successful women. Take it to the next level by bookmarking a dish to make together on your next night together. 

Help your lady treat herself to some at-home pampering with this ylang ylang and vanilla soak from husband-wife helmed Herbivore. 

This super cute pajama set says “I’m into you” without being too forward. 

Type-A S.O.’s will love this luxe daily planner with a foiled linen cover and ribbon bookmark. Bonus points: pencil in a super special surprise date for a few weeks in advance for the thoughtful gift that keeps on giving. 

Keep your message clear with this cozy jacquard throw by artist Clint Soren. 

The perfect thoughtful token for your new nap queen, this pure silk eyemask delivers the ultimate in beauty sleep.